REVIEWER GUIDELINES

Title of paper reviewed:
……………………………………………….………….………….

 Reviewer Summary:

The recommendation is:

  1. Accept without change
  2. Accept subject to minor revisions
  3. Major revision required and resubmit
  4. Reject

Reviewer Responses:

i.    The paper is within the scope of the Journal of Organics ….Y/N.
ii.   The research is well conceived ….Y/N.
iii.  The research is clearly reported ….Y/N.
iv.  The paper is well written ….Y/N.
v.    The Abstract is adequate ….Y/N.
vi.   The Introduction is adequate ….Y/N.
vii.  The Methods section is adequate ….Y/N.
viii. The Results are adequately reported ….Y/N.
ix.   Graphs & images are adequate & adequately labelled ….Y/N/NA
x.    The Conclusions expressed are justified ….Y/N.

Reviewer Comments:


Email review to: editor@jorganics.org

Advertisements

jOrganics.org